Yes, Tony is Gay. And Mr. Saturn is Innocent

LOL, my gaydar was right!

I think Porky/Pokey might not be as straight as he seems. Remember the oxygen machine/big-lipped centaur-man in his bedroom besides all the beautiful women? And how he keeps Ness’ old yo-yo like a precious item, when he was supposed to detest him…

Were did Itoi get the idea of creating Ness as a boy wearing a red baseball cap?

That’s what Aidan wants to know.

Tony needs to have some intrest in girls somehow!

not when he’s stuck at a boarding school full of guys…

And that’s one MORE Fobbies Are Borange reference explained…(meaning I never thought he was gay until hearing it on FaB, and this is the first time I’ve personally read confirmation of that point.)

He must’ve been so excited on his first day, and I mean EXCITED.

He doesn’t need an interest in girls, and just because he’s gay doesn’t make him boy crazy.

Way to completely miss the point of Itoi’s inclusion of a gay character with nondescript sexual tendencies, guys.

Tony doesn’t need an interest in girls, just like straight guys don’t need an interest in other guys. See how that works?

I think it’s pretty cool that Itoi added some gay characters into the game. Now if only we could get some handicapped people in on this…

MOTHER 4: WHEELCHAIRBOUND

I thought it was extremely obvious that Tony was gay,just by the way he talks to Jeff, and when you guys go to school, do you fap to EVERY girl you see? no, so why would Tony.

What about Maxwell?
I’m pretty sure he was gay too.
I mean, when you save the game when you’re Jeff, he says “Go for it, bad boy!”

My gaydar has a blinking pink dot on it whenever Maxwell is around.

I wonder what Tony would be like in real life? Jeff was always my favorite character and he has similar hair to me and one of my friends is really obsessive and touches my shoulders a lot and I think he might be gay so I can realate to jeff.

2 aidan: well, in an unwritten fanfic of mine (Which is mother 4) Tony is best friends with the ness/ninten/lucas replacment, who is a girl. her name is Haley, and their is no love intrest between them. this story is acully suposed to be a “comedy for the heck of it” fic but heres a quote from it: “our only hope is…… a girl with a temper, the brother of a villian, a gay guy and a robot dog?! we’re done for…..”

2 want latios lots: there is a handicapped main character: Duster.

my gaydar must be broken because I didn’t see that coming really…

I guess all of that JeffxTony yaoi isn’t too out there…

I think it’s awesome that Itoi outed Tony, that way people can see that we’re not all pink rainbow stereotypes on parade who like to molest every man we see, we’re regular people with feelings and emotions.

How do we know he’s talking about Tony?

@Some Guy– “A really passionate friend who lives in an England-like place.”

I knew it!

i love you boys

its barrny

billy shears uses PK love

Tony must feel like a guy going to an all-girls boarding school. Don’t deny it. There’s gotta be some desire there.

The newest GTA4 expansion pack is called “The Ballad of Gay Tony”. Coincidence? I disbelieve so.

there are a lot of gay characters in the mother games, also some dialogues ans scenes…..itoi must be gay. that would awesome

And henceforth, millions of Yaoi fangirls squealed their little heads off.

I know this is disturbing, but before I actually looked at some more stuff up, I originally thought tony was A GIRL. ( It was the first comic I read with Tony in it to blame, because he acted so girlyin it)

sorry, it’s “girly in it”

actually, the yoyo is in one of fassad’s rooms and dont scroll down if you dont lke spoilers.

fassad is a magypsy so he is neither man nor woman. (as it says in the game)

I think Maxwell is gay as well. When you call him to save your game, he says this:
“Go for it, bad boy!”
I know that’s not a gay line, but it sounds gay.

HAHAHAHA I KNEW IT!!!!
TONY IS GAY BECAUSE HIS NAME [no offense people whose name if tony and is not gay] AND HIS MOUTH [yet again, no offense to gay people, i’m not gay, but after what that Ricky Martin guy said, i felt glad that he said it, but seriously, i’m not gay!] you see, my brother’s friend’s Brother is gay, and an ex-friend of my other brother [who wanted to be a preist when he grew up, but didn’t] became gay after being roomates with another man.
AND DO NOT UNDERESTIMATE mR. SatUrN B@InG

Hooray! I’m glad to see Mr. Itoi’s choice for diversity! I think it’s wonderfull that more minorities are being represented in today’s media such as this (even if this game is from 1995).

Now I wonder if Jeff’s school is like the one from Strawberry Panic! If so, I’m glad Ness busted him out of there!

Check EB_Jeff’s newest Tweet. 0_0

I knew Tony was gay, you could just tell by the way his mouth is.

lol, poor Jeff, XD!

^^LOLOL, thats ultimate proof. It sure seemed that way so I guess it’s nice to hear… Also cool about doseisan and talking about Forrest Gump!

That’s why people on youtube said Jeff was teased with names like, “Gay Activist”?

Come to think of it, I’m a living Tony…… BTW HI Psi Paula

I knew tony was gay, hell im gay, big deal,
Sexual ornintation is nothing major, it does not kill any one. but still i have no clue how i survied the ’80 unharmed

Tony is gay, but most likely for Jeff. Do you remember at one point that Tony calls Jeff and asks for your name? Once you confirm your name, he just didn’t seem to feel like ending the call. That’s proof enough for the lot of us. XD

My sister is a JeffXTony fangirl. I should hide this article from her. To stay on topic I never wouldn’t thought Tony was gay, especially since Tony and my friend are very similar.

I think the line that catches my attention most in this article is “They weren’t called Mr. Saturn at first, but they gained that name during development.” I am now extremely curious what their original name was…

You know what’s funny? There is a Grand Theft Auto IV DLC Called The Ballard Of Gay Tony. XD

I don’t get it. This whole idea of Tony being homosexual sounds retrofitted.

Itoi… you are so weird…

I knew it.

IM GAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY!!!!!!!!!

i have one question to ask to everybody…………..
……………………………………………..

HOW IS HE GAYYYY I know itoi creatid him but is there a story??????? >:O

Well, when you’re in a room full of guys all day, you gotta adapt…X9

I’m not gay!

Why do so many people (especially guys) care so much about other guys’ sexuality. It kinda makes them seem gay…

Oh and shut up about Grand Theft Auto, please.

but is tony fake?

“Opening pk hack”

That is really cool of Itoi to have a gay character in EB. People sometimes act rude to those who are different and it was just really neat that he made the world of Mother more realistic by creating a character like that. But hey, I have a gay friend, and he’s really nice.

As a gay teenager playing Earthbound in the mid-90s, when it came to the scene with Tony, I couldn’t help but think, “Is he gay? He must be gay.” It was a great feeling to be able to identify with a character (albeit ancillary) in such an epic story. Thanks Mr. Itoi!

Not stated in the game? Then it doesn’t mean anything.
Just a theory.

“Not stated in the game? Then it doesn’t mean anything.
Just a theory.”

This is really stupid, “honesty”. First off, anyone who knows anything about science knows that theories need evidence! And there is MUCH evidence, considering how Tony seems to care “much more than expected” for his “best friend”. Also, you are misunderstanding the nature of art, especially the idea Death of the Author. Just because something isn’t stated DIRECTLY in a game doesn’t mean the audience can’t make their own interpretations, ESPECIALLY considering the level of obviousness in the inneuendo that is gayness.

LOL -bunny

The ballad of Gay Tony, lulz.

I knew he was gay! That whole ‘dream’ comment when you first play as Jeff… I knew it.

I wouldn’t have guessed he was gay. I just thought he eas annoying but not gay?

I think tony is gay as well (As proven by Itoi’s interview)

But when you play Chrono trigger, you run into Flea, and he’s even more gay than tony is.