Tips for Buying EarthBound

March 22nd, 2010 | EarthBound, Images

Javi sent this in the other day:

Hey Tomato,

A while back I made something for one of my class projects. It was a class magazine, and I decided to write up something for the review section. Well, yeah, I reviewed EarthBound. I designed it myself, except for the clay models of course. It’s not that great, and I wonder about other people’s EarthBound related projects… By the way, it’s 4 pages long.

That’s actually pretty slick looking for a class project! I’m sure people will have different opinions about the review score and all that stuff, but the overall score seems fair to me.

I guess this was also the basis for one of the custom ads on this site, the one that talks about evil trees and stuff 😛

 

Other Related Posts:

 

28 Comments to EarthBound School Project


IWANNAPIZZAAIRFRESHENER said on Mar. 22, 2010

I srsly wish people would stop coming down on the graphics 🙁

DayvanMollusk said on Mar. 22, 2010

I totally agree with IWANNAPIZZAAIRFRESHENER. And damn near every snes game ends up using a pallet switch for enemies at some point or another. Other than that nice work!

20thCenturyBoy said on Mar. 22, 2010

Bad review. The Screenshot is missing.

Just kidding XD

That’s one nice class project^^

neonix said on Mar. 22, 2010

When I was a kid playing it for the first time, I thought the graphics were good actually.

Also, I like how “The ending gives you nightmares” is in the good column. 🙂

JudgeDeadd said on Mar. 22, 2010

Awesome graphics design.

Portal-Kombat said on Mar. 22, 2010

Here are the scores I gave to EarthBound.
Story: 8.5 Seems simple at first, but becomes deeper later in the game.
Gameplay: 8 Sometimes boring, but many hilarious and fun parts make up for it.
Graphics: 8.5 Underrated, imaginative, and sometimes reminds me of South Park.
Sound: 9 Sound effects are annoying, music is awesome except for some battles.
Cast: 10 Memorable, quirky characters you actually seek out to talk to them!
Lasting Appeal: 8 The ending and the beginning flow together really well, so it makes one want to play it again. However, I think it drags around Fourside.
Overall: 8.7/10

Joshua Johnson said on Mar. 22, 2010

The teacher probobly wanted to keep that project

clausman said on Mar. 22, 2010

nice job. i should have thought of it myself. i give you a 9.5.

Tetra said on Mar. 22, 2010

A+

neonix said on Mar. 22, 2010

@Portal-Kombat, what do you mean by “it drags around Fourside”? I ask because it must be something major for you to knock off 2 points.

Dumbo said on Mar. 23, 2010

Psssh, 10/10 for me. Best RPG I’ve ever played (And I’ve played alot of RPGs).

sigh said on Mar. 23, 2010

Yeah, i’d say that’s a fair assement. I could never, in any good consciousness give Earthbound a perfect ten for any reason, simply due to the presence of games that were always much better and technically superior to it in a lot of ways. earthbound has always been sort of “the little underdog that could” of RPG, but when viewed fairly, it’s just not up there.

Personally, though I love earthbound for reasons relating to it’s story, it’s characterization and it’s tone which are all masterful, I always felt the game barely deserved more than a 7.0. I think the game is very good in it’s look and feel, and particularly it’s characterization but it has many flaws that really drag it down, a lot.

In essense, Earthbound is an emotional experence unlike any other (Until Mother 3 came along). On the other hand, on the technical aspect of things, it is a rather generic RPG system, that is miles behind other games of the era. The battle system was woefully outdated for it’s day, and as an RPG on simply the RPG level, it is standard, at best.

It is simply not any more well constructed than one of the more primitive Dragon Warrior games from the NES when it comes to it’s core gameplay. I never thought the graphics were a problem. I feel Earthbound’s greatest weakness is that it takes it’s unique and amazing world and plops it into an RPG system that is both dull to play through, and adds or innovates practically nothing aside from a rolling HP counter, which, if you think about it, really adds nothing at all to the real gameplay instead of just being kind of cool looking.

The characters and the quirky and lovely world more than makes up for these faults, almost singlehandedly giving the game all 7 of it’s points out of 10 that make the game unforgettable and emotional. Playing it all the way through, however, can feel tedious since again there’s little strategy or innovation outside of a basic Dragon Warrior title.

Gameplay-wise, if you ignore the humor, wit, charm, and emotional value, Earthbound has nothing on he techinal gameplay side that Square-Enix hadn’t done and done much better with games like Final Fantasy 6 and Chrono Trigger.

Therefore, it just can’t be rated anywhere near as high as those, although Earthbound does undeniably have a place as an underdog and recgonized for a game that does have a large fanbase and does deserve that fan-base.

If Earthbound had an innovative RPG gameplay system in place that lived up to it’s near limitless charm, then it might have very well been one of the greatest games ever, but in actual it’s gameplay is just as shallow as it’s world is unique, which really unbalances the game’s potential. That is, when someone looks at the game FAIRLY as opposed to blindly nostalgic. Which is sadly, how this game is looked at, with it’s reputation, and most, blindly giving it a 10 out of 10 score that it really doesn’t deserve.

Earthbound, in my view is really good. Not great, not a masterpeice, but just good. It does however coast along entirely on the value of it’s charm, but ultimately doesn’t have the substance that other games of it’s era have. Earthbound, to me, is like a game that wins you over with it’s dazzling smile, and charming personality and then is somewhat shallow on the inside. You can learn to live with it’s flaws and outdated, un-innovative gameplay because it’s charming, cute, and touching in it’s own way, but I never really found it to be a fulfillin GAMING experience. Just an emotional one.

To be a well-rounded game or to truly deserve a 10/10, a game has to have BOTH. Earthbound has one. It does one extremely well which makes up for exactly half of it plus an extra 20% for it’s beauty and charm alone, but it still only has one. Hence where I think the game basically earns a 50% for charm alone and an extra 20% for the sheer beauty of it’s smile. But the rest that would figure into it’s gameplay is nonexistant since it’s woefully behind what other games have done vastly better.

Earthbound needed to push the boundries of an RPG and go beyond other games, not just in the emotional factor, but in the gameplay department. It refuses to do that and does kind of suffer for it.

Fanboys may not like that review, even though i’m still saying it’s an important, good, and enjoyable game despite glaring flaws. But I could never logically say this game was a little bit beyond average, especially for it’s day.

PKSTARMAN said on Mar. 23, 2010

Great but there’s something I don’t understand, It’s not about the project, It’s about why Nintendo would go saying that game was stinky?! It’s one of their games! I would understand if they were saying sonic was stinky! (For Sonic fans, I’m sorry for that but It’s what Ninendo thought of Sonic by those years)

PKSTARMAN said on Mar. 23, 2010

EarthBound is 2nd best game I’ve ever played, the 1st place goes to Chrono Trigger.

Poe said on Mar. 23, 2010

PKSTARMAN – NOA were latching on to the fact that you can fight weird, smelly creatures like piles of puke in EarthBound. They weren’t saying that EB stinks as in it’s a terrible game, but it can certainly be interpreted that way.

Sweet-Michiko said on Mar. 23, 2010

I think at the time, they were trying to cash in on the fad of gross-stinky things and it backfired severely. Think back to Gak and Silly Putty, Creepy Crawlers and that Dr. Dreadful brains and body parts making kit thing. There were others, but you get the idea.

Megalosaro said on Mar. 24, 2010

One of the reasons my father and I decided to buy EarthBound back in the 90s as a blind buy was because we thought the graphics were cool 🙁

Anonymous said on Mar. 24, 2010

Wow I find it funny how he rated the game graphics badly. It was made in 1994-1995 So he should try thinking in his head how graphics were back then and not now.

Poe said on Mar. 24, 2010

^ I think he already was. When you compare EB to other games released at the time (Chrono Trigger, Super Mario RPG, Donkey Kong Country), EB’s graphics definitely leave a lot to be desired.

Javi said on Mar. 24, 2010

WOAH, My review!

Anyway, I dunno, I love the graphics. Hahaha, I just think I needed a fair review… I just based its score on other games released during the time. Sorry to those who have different opinions on it…

EarthBound’s graphics are unique, cute, and awesome, and any other way would’ve just made the game lame. It’s very beautiful and colorful. It fits the game the way it needs to. Hahaha.

EarthBound gets a 10 from me, but as a reviewer highschool student dude, I can’t just do that.

And yeah, I designed that ad. I’m really happy it’s on the site. Well, thanks for sharing your opinions on it. 🙂

Shann said on Mar. 26, 2010

are you sure this is a school project? are you positive this isn’t a magazine clipping or something?

…nah, couldn’t be. this is better than all the crap game magazines were trying to feed us in 1995, saying that earthbound was awful D:

but seriously, this is the nicest review of earthbound i’ve ever read. you identify all the good points and the bad points perfectly. this is great.

Mr. Saturn said on Mar. 27, 2010

Sorry if this is off topic, but…
Does Picky remind anyone else of Numbah 4 from Kids Next Door?

Dookie said on Mar. 28, 2010

I agree with you Javi. People always comment on how the gfx are below average. They are missing the point. EB is a highly stylized game, and it would really look kind of retarded to have like super realistic ala chrono trigger graphics in my opinion.

Javi said on Mar. 28, 2010

Haha, maybe I should’ve given the game a 7 or 8 instead of 6 in the graphics part.

Anyway, what I was trying to show in my review is that a game’s graphics don’t need to be great to make a great game. In my opinion, I love the game’s graphics style, but they should have improved on the style they used, and they perfected this in Mother 3. \m/

But what truly makes EarthBound a great game is the way that the game absorbs you into its world, and makes you a part of it, not just a person controlling characters, not just a person being dragged by a plot, but a member of the game itself.

Sean Peden said on Apr. 25, 2010

“The ending gives you nightmares”

Oh god it does.

radio active ping pong squirrels said on May. 28, 2011

i wish i could do that for my project.

DaL33T said on Dec. 4, 2011

I should do something like this for my high school newspaper.

Nyx said on Feb. 19, 2012

Lawsuits.


 
 

Recent Comments

  • .: I once bought Metroid: Other M for $5 at Best Buy in the bargain bin. It wasn’t the greatest Metroid ever, but for $5 it was a great game!
  • Sato: @Apple Kid It’s probably a UK SNES, which has the same design as the Super Famicom. There’s the possibility that this is a...
  • EileenThePizzaQueen: @adex As a (mediocre) feminist I want so badly to be able to defend you here. I absolutely get why you’d be...
  • StarmanAlex: JERRY JERRY JERRY JERRY
  • adex: “Mother2fan” is just some perverted eurocreep who thinks females should be subjected to the naked male form whenever the...
Subscribe to Comments Feed!

Archives

Search

Official EarthBound Figures!